The proposition of this thread is flawed, for the same reason he pointed it.
If you queue solo, or with 1 friend, and you get 2 nawbs, 1 with an ECM interceptor, and the other with some guard for example.
If you and your friend goes for the “optimal ships” in second phase of blackwood T3, you get your brilliant maulers, all purpled up doing a fuckton of dammage, before you melt the first station, your 2 palls die, and you are swarmed with AI’s and die aswell.
Then you would have wasted a lot of minutes, and have to requeue (which sometimes takes a little while) and repeat the same mistake…
While for example, when me and my brother are playing together, if i see the other 2 have no brain, i get my bubble gunship, he gets his engie, and i keep focusing on turrets and adds, after some while (little longer, but still better that restarting all over again) all 3 stations are down, and the 2 nawbs are alive. Why do that? They atract aggro, and it is MUCH easier to eliminate a fuckton of enemy stacked to hit a nawb then when they are orbiting you, specially with bubbles.
My point being, if you cant have lets say, a 4-man LRFs to melt stations in less than a minute, and you have to rely on nawbs to complete the mission, best is for you to compensate for their lack of skill, even if that is unfair…to carry stupid people around. But even if that tarded interceptor is making low dammage, it is better than no dammage at all.
Now, the main point, you said killing ships shouldnt count as helping on objectives, you are being blind, because if i for example dont keep the adds at bay, the whole team dies before the objectives are destroyed, so your argument is failed.
I agree that diferent stronger adds should be worth more points, for example, i can kill 5 fighter non elite fighters with 1 shot from a bubblegun, and get 100 points. While shooting 10 times on a elite fightert only gives me 20, or even worse, wasting a minute to kill those commanders elite to get only 20 points…
And if you start putting dammage on top priority to dictate efficiency you are going to have a bad time, because whats the best way to amass dammage? AOE, which class of ship has the most AOE? Torpedo boats, you will start seeing lot of people on torpedo frigs xxxx other people’s games.
By the time it takes a guard to die against mobs (and supposing he takes some of them) a single Tier 4 LRF (or better, a Mauler) can take down the three stations easily, if its properly tanked and with survival modules (why would you fit any other module in a PvE farmship?)
I have done it quite some times.