Waiting times in T3 have been highly reduced for 4-man-squads. In fact I had a lot of matches with a wait time <1 min.
There were changes made to the MM which the community isnt aware of (must have been done with the last patch).
Getting matched vs another equal sized squad is not viable. You can wait for ever. In fact the 9.12 patch killed most squadding completely, since nobody wanted to bear waiting all that time in the que, just to hope to find an other squad.
I strongly belive that squads should stay in their respective tier. Socializing is still the main incentive to play MMOs, if you take this chance away, the game becomes quite quickly boring.
In fact the whole series of 9.x patches made Squadding more and more painful every time, it felt like punishment. I belive that the current playerbase noticed that punishment and is not willing to squad up anymore. How many 4-man-squads do you see at the moment which are not ESB? So of course I will spend as much time queuing in 4-M-S as possible, since it will be gone pretty soon thanks to the whiners which dont want/can socialize.
If it was for me, the Devs should even propagate to fly in squads. Saying it is YOUR FAULT if you dont squad up, deal with it then!
And no. Squads are not always better. If they lack coordination they can be even worse than a bunch of PUGS.
The fact of the matter is that MM does NOT look for equal number squads, let alone balanced matches. You will, more often than not, without a shadow of a doubt, see a 4-man squad on one side of the match and, MAYBE, 2-3-man squads on the other side.
The problem isn’t “death squads” in matches, it’s how the MM handles them. The MM doesn’t give a toss what ships you have (ship roles, that is) and rightfully so. But it should NOT, also, give a damn if your ship is Free or Premium. As it stands, MM treats Premium ships 1 Rank lower, so R9 Premiums are, and have always been, considered as R8s. This is wrong. End of discussion.
You see A LOT of 4-man squads in almost every Tier. During December, I’ve been in T1/2/3, even in T4 and I’ve met 4-man squads in ALL OF THEM. On a regular basis, as well. 4-man quads exist. Are they effective? Well, depends on the individual pilot skill. I’ve seen it all, from actual death squad balls to squads who continuously suicide over and over and over just to attempt to capture a single Beacon in matches.
The point to 4-man squads is to both socialize and win games. But it still feels like a 1-sided battle, no matter the opposition (save for when ESB meets their match).
Overall, the MM still needs A LOT of work but, more importantly than that, the servers need work to accommodate MORE than 2300 pilots without gagging themselves and lagging everywhere. Until both those things happen, pilots will keep on quitting the game before they join it.